Which Cardstock Should You Choose for MTG Proxies?

When ordering MTG proxies, one of the biggest decisions you'll make is choosing the right cardstock. The artwork may be the first thing people notice, but the cardstock determines how the card feels in your hand, how it shuffles, and how closely it resembles an authentic Magic card.

Different cardstock options serve different purposes. Some are designed for affordable playtesting, while others focus on premium finishes or authentic card feel. Here's a closer look at the most popular options.

 

 

Partial Foil

 

Partial Foil is a favorite among players who want something visually impressive without sacrificing readability. Unlike traditional foil cards, only the artwork receives the holographic treatment. The card frame, text box, and borders remain clean and non-foil.

This creates a striking contrast that makes the artwork stand out while keeping card text easy to read. The result feels premium and unique without becoming overly flashy. For many players, Partial Foil strikes the perfect balance between aesthetics and practicality.

If you're building a Commander deck filled with showcase cards or custom artwork, Partial Foil is often the most versatile premium option available.

 

 

Holo Foil

 

For players who want maximum visual impact, Holo Foil is the obvious choice. The holographic effect extends across the entire card, creating a bright and reflective finish that immediately grabs attention.

Holo Foil proxies are ideal for collectors, display pieces, or decks designed to stand out at the table. Every card has a premium appearance and a level of shine that standard finishes simply cannot match.

The tradeoff is that the additional reflectiveness can sometimes make text slightly harder to read under certain lighting conditions. If your priority is making your cards look spectacular, however, Holo Foil delivers exactly that.

 

 

Standard Paper

 

Standard Paper is the most economical option and is primarily intended for playtesting. If you're experimenting with deck ideas, trying out expensive cards before purchasing them, or regularly updating your lists, Standard Paper provides excellent value.

Despite its lower cost, modern printing methods still produce vibrant colors and sharp images. The cards look good on the table, even if they don't perfectly replicate the feel of authentic trading cards.

For casual testing and budget-conscious players, Standard Paper remains a practical choice that gets the job done without unnecessary expense.

 

 

S30 Black Core

 

If your goal is to create proxies that feel as close to real Magic cards as possible, S30 Black Core is generally considered the premium option.

This cardstock is printed on the same style of stock commonly used throughout the trading card industry. The black core layer improves opacity while providing the weight, stiffness, and shuffle feel players expect from a professionally manufactured card.

The difference becomes immediately noticeable when handling the cards. They feel sturdier, more authentic, and significantly closer to official card stock than standard paper alternatives.

For players building long-term Commander decks or premium proxy collections, S30 Black Core is often worth the additional cost.

 

 

Which Cardstock Is Best?

 

The answer depends entirely on your goals.

If you're simply testing a deck before investing in expensive singles, Standard Paper is the most cost-effective choice. If realism matters most, S30 Black Core provides the closest experience to an authentic MTG card. Players who want premium visuals without overwhelming shine will likely prefer Partial Foil, while those looking for maximum flash and collectability should choose Holo Foil.

Ultimately, there is no single "best" cardstock for MTG proxies. The best option is the one that matches how you intend to use your cards. Whether you're playtesting a new brew, upgrading your Commander deck, or creating a collection of stunning custom cards, choosing the right cardstock can make a significant difference in the final result.